Saturday 15 August 2020

Two film questions...

Which film has given you the greatest sense of another time and which has influenced your gaming most?

31 comments:

  1. I think for the greatest sense of another time it would have to be “The Duellists” for the beauty of the photography and look of the thing. For influencing my gaming it would have to be “ The Longships “ seen when young and caught my imagination. Fuelled my interest in history greatly.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Tricky first question. Two contenders for this: Captain Alatriste; and Hope and Glory. The past is a foreign country. And not just because Alatriste is about a Spanish soldier). The film gives a sense of a culture alien to us. The main character who is a hero in their terms is a complete and utter, argumentative, violent p***k in ours. Hope and Glory sets out to show us the world as we thought we knew it through the eyes of a young boy. The War through his eyes is a time of wonder and opportunity. Captain Alatriste just pips it.

    Second question is much easier for me. It has to be Waterloo. Went to see it when it came out (must have been 7 or 8) and it dispelled the idea I had from watching WWII films that soldiers fought running around and diving in the dirt! And it was splendid. After that my main interest was definitely the horse and musket era.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have heard of the Captain film, must give it a go. Waterloo is quite a film, have a souvenir programme from it in the loft somewhere,went with my Dad to see it.

      Delete
  3. The 300 Spartans (1962) as a child and more recently Apocalypse Now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Proper Sandals epic and what an iconic view apocalypse now is.

      Delete
  4. "The Warlord" subliminally influenced my wargaming as surely did "El Cid". Conjuring another time........I absolutely agree about" The Duellists" and would add "Barry Lindon" (pity they didn't stick closely to the original novella).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I recall the Warlord on tv. I nearly chose Barry Lyndon myself. That are just so many out there..

      Delete
  5. 'Waterloo' I think and of course 'Zulu' , of late 'Apocalypse Now' I think .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My Dad took me to Zulu, loved it. Other choices iconic in their own ways,

      Delete
  6. 55 Days at Peking, without a doubt.

    Must get this done in 28mm some day.

    ReplyDelete
  7. For the first "Queen Margot" a sweaty dirty image of royalty.
    The second is much harder because there has been so many movies. I'll pick "The Wind That Shakes the Barley". A conflict I've always had an interest in but not the style of game I would want to put on the table.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really like Queen Margot, visually stunning with fantastic female lead. The wind... is a powerful story indeed. I worked with someone whose mother had been in a situation similar to the B&Ts village raid as a wee girl.Listening to her speak about it has stayed with me.

      Delete
  8. As a child in the 60's it seemed there were almost constant reports and news footage of the war in Vietnam, my mother was in regular contact with a group of French missionaries working over there, their letters brought the conflict and suffering very close. Later when I started reading first hand accounts of the war I was shocked by the brutality and senselessness of it all, so when I first watched Apocalypse Now it brought all that back to me, the nihilism of random events and characters creating a surrealist world out of control.

    The film which has most influenced my wargaming must be Waterloo, the visual aspect of the hobby has always been paramount for me and it ticks all my boxes for grandiose scale and colour.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Apocalypse Now is so powerful and I am not surprised it brought that all back. Waterloo, the scale indeed...

      Delete
  9. Not films, but two TV series. Ivanhoe and Robin Hood for sense of another time. The benefit was it was in England, more easily relatable to. The 300 Spartans for influencing me in choice of gaming starting point.
    That is three great heroes.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If we are doing tv too ( and why not I say) it would have to be “Arthur of the Britains “ with Blessed, Praed etc. I loved it and the Flashing Blade!

      Delete
  10. Lawrence of Arabia and Barry Lyndon

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Listened to a very interesting radio programme about T E Lawerence the other day. Great film too. Barry Lyndon explains a lot about why people game the eighteenth century.

      Delete
  11. The Duellists or Master and Commander for period atmosphere.

    Wargaming inspiration: not a film, but a TV comedy show - Michael Bentine's It's a Square World, in which he used to do recreations of Balaclava &c with puffs of smoke for gunfire. He showed you could recreate battles in miniature. Bentine also had humorous Heath Robinson type weapons, such as the gas that dissolved trouser buttons so that enemy troops' braces would fail and they'd be reduced to holding their breeches up and thus be unable to fight.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Master & Commander, a splendid film. I recall Bentine’s Potty time which was similar in many ways.

      Delete
    2. I forgot Master & Commander. Superb all round. Great period feel.

      As for Michael Bentine’s Potty Time: “ah oui General!” I’ll never forget his Battle of Waterloo.

      Delete
  12. A toughie this, but Waterloo. I remember sitting in my local cinema dreaming of owning thousands of figures to re fight the battle. Still a brilliant spectacle. After that its a toss up between Taras Bulba or the Duelists, but then there is the Vikings and Spartacus.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The Vikings, Spartacus, Tara’s Bulba , just too many great films to choose from.

    ReplyDelete
  14. A Bridge Too Far is a firm favourite. Sink the Bismarck and Battle of the River Plate fueled my love of naval gaming.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great choice, I am partial to The Cruel Sea & In which we serve when it comes to Naval films too.

      Delete
  15. Thanks for reminding me of The Flashing Blade, great stuff! Set in the same period, The Last Valley was pretty good, I thought. There's no real clue which side the soldiers are fighting for until near the end - and from the villager's point of view, it made no difference.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I recall the Last Valley, Michael Caine etc. There was a character called Gruber if I recall correctly.

      Delete
  16. Sense of another time - can this be the grubby future of the first Star Wars?

    Most influential on my gaming - oddly a film I remember coming out when I was a child about Arnhem, A Bridge Too Far, even though I do not now usually game WW2 like I did as an Airfix kid. There are many things I dislike about this film, not least the star cameos, it is the strong linked narratives and the individual actions in the middle of chaos that I find fascinating. I caught a little of this again in Band of Brothers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Interesting choice, I haven’t seen it for years. I watched band of brothers some time ago and was most taken by it.

      Delete
  17. Some excellent film choices by everyone, quite a few of which I have never seen. This morning - what a difference a day makes - my most influential film on gaming is now hovering somewhere between the acrobatic fight scenes in The Magnificent Seven (or every cowboy film I've seen), the shoot outs in Morecambe and Wise's the Magnificent Two, and the battle scenes of Carry on Up the Khyber Pass. Ho hum ...

    ReplyDelete